Freelance Isn't Free Act · Penalties & Damages
What a client actually risks by not paying you.
The Freelance Isn't Free Act's damages, itemized by a New York attorney.
Most freelancers ask for the invoice amount. New York law says you can be owed considerably more than that. Understanding the Act's penalty structure changes the negotiation, because once your client understands it, an unpaid $5,000 invoice stops looking like a debt they can ignore and starts looking like a $10,000-plus problem.
Provided through DemandLetterNY.com, a service of Hochman Law PC.
The headline number: double damages for nonpayment.
NY GEN. BUS. LAW ART. 44-A · FREELANCE ISN'T FREE ACT
If a hiring party fails to pay a covered freelancer on time: by the contract date, or within 30 days of completing the work when no date is set: the Freelance Isn't Free Act lets the freelancer recover damages equal to double the unpaid amount, plus reasonable attorney's fees and costs. An ignored $5,000 invoice becomes a $10,000 exposure before the client's own legal bills are counted.
No written contract: its own violation, its own damages.
The Act requires the client to provide a written contract for covered work. If they didn't, that alone supports statutory damages of $250. If the missing contract is combined with other violations: like not paying: the statute authorizes damages equal to the value of the underlying contract, on top of the double damages for nonpayment. The client's "nothing was in writing" defense is, literally, an admission. More on that in what to do with no written contract.
Retaliation: value of the contract, again.
Threatening, blacklisting, or penalizing a freelancer for asserting rights under the Act is a separate violation, with damages equal to the value of the contract for each act of retaliation. A client who answers your payment request with "ask again and you'll never work in this industry" has usually just increased what they owe.
Attorney's fees shift the math completely.
In ordinary contract disputes, each side pays its own lawyer, which is why chasing small invoices used to be uneconomical. The Act flips that: a prevailing freelancer recovers reasonable attorney's fees from the client. That is why a single attorney demand letter citing the Act: see what it contains, so often ends the dispute: a rational business will not risk double damages plus two sets of legal fees over one invoice.
How the exposure stacks up.
- Unpaid $5,000 invoice, contract in writing: up to $10,000 (double damages) + your attorney's fees.
- Same invoice, no written contract: up to $10,000 + up to $5,000 (contract-value damages) + fees.
- Client retaliates when you ask: add contract-value damages again.
These are the statute's ceilings, not a promise of any particular recovery; courts decide actual awards. But the client's lawyer will read the same statute you just did.
How to actually claim them.
Work the sequence in the step-by-step playbook: paper trail, one written demand from you, then an attorney demand letter that itemizes this exposure, then an administrative complaint or court. Mind the clock: claims about the written-contract requirement have a two-year window, while nonpayment and retaliation claims have six years: details in how long you have to act.
A flat-fee demand letter drafted and signed by a New York attorney often resolves it without a lawsuit. Start online at DemandLetterNY.com, a service of Hochman Law PC, or learn more about flat-fee demand letters.
Questions people ask us.
Are double damages automatic?
No. They are what the statute authorizes a court to award for late or nonpayment; most matters settle before any award, but the exposure is what motivates settlement.
Does the Act apply to my invoice?
It covers freelance work in New York worth $800 or more, alone or aggregated across 120 days for the same client, performed as an independent contractor. Most professional freelance invoices qualify.
Can I demand double the invoice in my own email?
You can accurately state that the Act authorizes double damages. An attorney demand letter typically itemizes the full exposure, which lands differently coming from a law firm.
What if the client simply has no money?
A judgment against an insolvent client is real but slower to collect. This is a reason to act early, while the business is still operating, not a reason to wait.
One Firm, Every Case Below
Owed money or wronged another way? We handle that too.
Stop chasing. Start demanding.
A flat-fee attorney demand letter, started online in minutes.